E-Invoice Penalties: Strategies to Minimize Penalties

Understanding penalty for e invoice is a very important part of businesses registered as taxpayers under GST. GST e-invoice penalty can create a lot of financial as well as non-financial burdens for a business. consequences of not generating IRN are very bad for business as they might lead to problems such as penalties and loss of reputation. So, to avoid these consequences businesses need to follow e invoice rules. Every GST registered Taxpayer having a turnover of more than INR 500 crores in any Financial Year from 2017-18 had to implement the E-Invoicing mechanism mandatorily from 1 October 2020. Furthermore, Taxpayers with a turnover of more than INR 100 crores in any Financial Year from 2017-18 have to implement this new invoicing system from 1 January 2021. Under the e-invoicing system, Taxpayers have to raise invoices in their internal systems and submit them to the Invoice Registration Portal (IRP).

The IRP will validate the invoice details generate an Invoice Reference Number (IRN) and a Quick Response (QR) code and send back the signed e-invoice with these details (IRN and QR code) to the Taxpayer. The invoice shared with the buyer should mandatorily contain the QR code. In case a Taxpayer fails to generate an e-invoice when required, it will be a default on his/her part. In other words, non-generation of e-invoice will imply that the supply transaction is not intimated to the Government when it is mandatory to do so and it brings penalty for e-invoice non-compliance.

What Are the Types of Penalties Under E-invoice?

There are majorly two main types of e-Invoicing penalty namely-

1. e-Invoicing penalty for non-issuance of E-Invoice- penalty for not generating e invoice is applicable when a supplier fails to generate an e-invoice when a taxable supply is made. This penalty is equivalent to 100% of the amount of tax applicable on supply or Rs10000, whichever is higher. penalty for non issuance of e invoice under gst section 31 rule 48(5) is applicable in this case.

2. e-Invoicing penalty for incorrect invoice- penalty for non generation of e invoice becomes applicable when a supplier creates an incorrect or improper invoice. The amount of fine for incorrect e-invoice is Rs25000 per invoice.

Consequences of Not Generating E-invoice?

Non-generation of e-invoice or irn not generated implies that the transaction of supply is not intimated to the government. Non-generation of e-invoices can create a huge burden on the cash flow and reputation of businesses that attract e invoice applicability. The consequences of non-generating e-invoice may include a fine and penalty being imposed on the supplier for failure in the generation of e-invoice or for generation of incorrect invoice. As per e invoice penalty section 31 of Rule 48(4), Not registering B2B invoice details on the Invoice Registration Portal for IRN amounts to the non-issuance of the invoice.

How to Identify That an Invoice Is Incorrect or Invalid?

An invoice is considered incorrect due to the following reasons-

1. When an invoice not generated as per the prescribed format of the e-invoicing schema.

2. If the invoice does not contain the mandatory fields as prescribed by the e-invoice schema notified by the government.

3. If the GSTIN mentioned in the invoice is not valid or is inactive at the present time.

4. The generated e-invoice duplicates a previous invoice for which an IRN was issued.

5. Taxpayers whose turnover amounts to Rs. 100 crore or more are required to submit invoices and credit-debit notes to the IRP and the time limit to generate e invoice for them is within 7 days from the invoice date, starting May 1, 2023. If they fail to do so those invoices will be deemed non-compliant.

If the supplier issues an incorrect e-invoice and uses it for the transportation of goods it is considered as an offence and is liable to an E-invoice error penalty. 

What Are the Consequences of Non-compliance With E-invoicing Regulations?

Non-compliance with e invoice rules or consequences of not generating IRN for the taxable person are as follows-

Detainment of goods in transit by the authorities-

Transporting goods without being accompanied by an e-way bill and e-invoice is deemed invalid, it may result in the detention of the goods in transit under Section 129 of the CGST Act 2017. Any invoice that does not contain an IRN and a signed QR code is considered invalid wherever applicable. Further, such transportation could also lead to the detention of goods and vehicles, and it may also attract penalties defined for e-way bills and IRN generation penalty.

GST-registered buyers may face denial of invoice payments, while Input Tax Credit (ITC) claims may also be withheld.

Under The GST Act, a tax invoice serves as vital evidence for claiming an Input Tax Credit (ITC). Section 16 of the CGST Act 2017 specifies that a registered buyer cannot avail of ITC unless they possess a valid tax invoice or debit note, and the ITC is eligible as per GSTR-2B.

In cases where buyers are presented with invalid or incorrect invoices lacking IRN and a signed QR code, the buyer has the right to reject the delivery of goods or withhold payment. Such actions can affect or delay the buyer's ability to claim ITC, which may also result in impacting their relationships with taxpayers and attract a GST e-invoice penalty.

Also, the details of invoices without IRN cannot be auto-populated into the supplier's GSTR-1, thus not reflected in the buyer's GSTR-2A and GSTR-2B. Also, the buyer cannot claim ITC for amounts where the supplier hasn't deposited the tax with the government.

It may cause delays and affect the generation of e-way bill

Failure to generate e-invoices or errors in their content can have repercussions on e-way bills, impacting logistics and potentially causing delays in delivery.

The cumbersome task of timely correction of e-way bills and e-invoices 

Taxpayers may encounter challenges due to GST e-invoice non-compliance and need to invest time and effort in rectifying errors found in e-invoices and e-way bills. Rectification within 24 hours allows for cancellation and re-issuance of a new invoice, enabling the generation of a new IRN and auto-generation of a new e-way bill. However, delays in correction beyond 24 hours necessitate the generation of credit notes or debit notes to make amendments.

How Can E-invoicing Penalties Affect the Business?

The business of taxpayer is impacted by e-invoice penalties in several ways such as-

It impacts Financially

penalty for e invoicing under gst is heavy and can be a considerable financial obligation for a business.

It damages and affects the goodwill

e-invoice penalty may affect the goodwill of the business which will in turn lead to hardship in the acquisition of customers and might also affect relationships with existing customers and partners.

It may lead to legal action against the business

Non-payment of GST e-invoice penalty on time due to any reason might lead to legal action being taken against the business by the authorities.

It may disturb the business operations

The smooth functioning of business operations may be disrupted as the company may need to spend time in making correction in the e-invoices and other inaccuracies.

ITC claim of customers may be disrupted

The customers may not be able to claim their ITC due to inaccuracies and might be facing financial strains. This will impact the relationship with customers.

Different Strategies to Avoid Non-compliance of E-invoicing?

The following are the things that should be done to avoid Non-compliance of e-invoicing-

Timely production of e-invoices

Businesses ought to generate e-invoices promptly following any taxable supply. This practice ensures alignment with e-invoicing rules thus preventing e-Invoicing penalty.

Accuracy checks on e-invoices

Prior to transmitting e-invoices, businesses should conduct comprehensive accuracy checks. This measure helps prevent e-Invoicing penalty for incorrect invoice

Utilization of reliable e-invoice solutions

Employing trustworthy e-invoice software such as Masters India e-invoice software for generating and sending e-invoices is crucial. Doing so helps businesses maintain compliance with e-invoicing standards and minimize the risk of e-Invoicing penalty. The software must be updated from time to time or the latest e-invoicing schema or format. The software should also contain time-limit validation to alert for any possible delays in reporting invoices to IRP and also avoid the same.

Conclusion.

Understanding e-invoicing penalties is crucial for businesses under GST, as non-compliance can result in financial burdens and reputational damage. While there may be penalty for not issuing e invoice or incorrect invoices, it's important to stay updated on waiver of penalty for e invoice or e invoice penalty notification. Utilizing resources such as an invoicing penalty calculator can help businesses navigate compliance efficiently. To avoid non-compliance, businesses should produce e-invoices promptly, conduct accuracy checks, and utilize reliable e invoice penalty notification pdf, while staying informed about the e invoice time limit latest notification, and notifications issued by relevant authorities.

Need of GST In Points | GST Invoice Series Rules | Powers of Revisional Authority Under GST | Kaju GST Rate | Maintenance GST Rate